Here’s Why We Need Student Loan Forgiveness Right Now

by | Jul 30, 2020 | Paying for College

A close examination of wealth in the U.S. shows the deep inequalities faced by Black Americans.

From earning gaps to student loan debt, and retirement savings, the disparity is staggering.

In 1963, the average wealth of white families was $121,000 higher than the average wealth of nonwhite families. By 2016, white family wealth was seven times greater than black family wealth.

Fast forward to 2020 where wealth disparities persist at an alarming rate.

Much of this is rooted in centuries of systemic racist policies.

In an earlier blog, I discussed reparations and some longer-term policies. While it is a start, we have a lot more work to do.

Today I share thoughts on an immediate solution to effectively reduce racial wealth inequality: Student Debt Cancellation.

The Case for Student Debt Forgiveness

I want to start with the elephant in the room.  We never should have allowed student debt to become the financial aid tool we use to assist students. 

This is especially true when you consider how it has affected low-income/low-wealth households.

Asking disadvantaged populations to mortgage their future was and is irresponsible. You shouldn’t have to finance higher education through debt.

Worse than that, you shouldn’t have to listen to trite advice that says “don’t worry, it will all pay off.” 

We didn’t see the obstacle course that it was to complete college and find a good-paying job.

We also failed to recognize the structural racism, sexism, and elitism that they’d face. These three are baked into our system, tripping them up every step of the way. 

So we leave them standing alone to pick up the pieces and pay back their debt.

The unfortunate part is that there is no end in sight. Financing college education through debt is more common than ever. And it continues to aggravate existing racial, social, economic, and gender inequalities. 

Data shows that for all racially marginalized groups in the United States, pursuing higher education and repaying student debt is disproportionately burdensome.

Why Cancelling Student Debt Makes Sense

Studies show that canceling student debt reduces racial wealth inequality. 

Using the most up to date data, Steinbaum shows that the more debt cancellation there is, the more racial wealth inequality is reduced. 

Findings indicate that those with lower economic status hold the lion’s share of outstanding student debt. 

While student debt was once a marker of privilege, it has become a mark of lack of privilege.

The spread of coronavirus and its economic destruction are once again exacerbating racial inequalities and wealth disparities. 

The lack of centralized strategic response to managing the COVID-19 pandemic coupled with the government’s unwillingness to listen and enter a dialogue with civil rights activists is setting our nation onto a destructive path.

While drafting the new stimulus package, Congress shouldn’t miss an important opportunity.  They have the chance to hear and meet the demands of those marginalized for too long. 

Instead, troubling news is emerging from the Republican Senate and Trump administration officials.  It is clear they are unwilling to provide relief or protection to borrowers in their proposed HEALS Act

The automatic suspension on student debt repayment will likely not be extended. This will have disastrous effects: 

  • Millions of struggling student loan borrowers will have to resume  monthly payments
  • These payments start in October even though many face layoffs or smaller paychecks 

Details of the plan also show that borrowers will need to choose between two ‘simpler’ repayment plan options: 

  • A standard 10-year mortgage-like plan 
  • An income-based plan 

This untimely simplification of the repayment schedules actually risks penalizing many borrowers who will be forced to move into more expensive repayment plans.

The proposed HEALS Act completely misses the mark. Now, more than ever, it is time to address the urgent needs of borrowers and to recognize that student debt is a pressing equity issue. 

Congress should pass legislation that relieves struggling borrowers through widespread student debt cancellation. All borrowers, public or private student debt holders, would get included.

For those whose student debt won’t be completely eliminated, the repayment pause should be extended.

Even before the COVID-19 pandemic, the United States was facing a student debt crisis. 

By underfunding higher education and passing the costs onto students in the form of heavy student debt, we have widened wealth inequalities, particularly racial wealth disparities.

There is no better time to reverse course by canceling student debt and adequately funding our higher education system to make it a debt-free proposition for students.

Share our story with others!

Help us spread the word about the important work we’re doing.